← Back to all articles

5 November 2026

Earned settlement: what the Government’s response means for people seeking ILR

Irfan Khan

Principle Solicitor

The Government has published its response to the consultation on earned settlement. The proposals would replace the usual five-year route to indefinite leave to remain (ILR) with a system in which the qualifying period depends on a person’s contribution, immigration history and circumstances.

The response sets out the Government’s policy decisions, but it does not itself change the Immigration Rules. The Government says it will publish detailed rules, operational guidance and an impact assessment before implementation. It has not announced a start date. Until the relevant Rules change, settlement applications remain governed by the Rules currently in force.

What is earned settlement?

Under the proposed system, time in the UK would not, by itself, be enough to qualify for settlement. Applicants would need to meet minimum requirements, and their qualifying period would depend on factors such as earnings, eligible public service, British family connections, access to specified public funds and immigration compliance.

The Government’s framework provides for 3, 5, 10 and 20-year pathways, as well as separate arrangements for refugees and certain other groups. The details may still change when the proposals are translated into Immigration Rules.

The proposed 3, 5, 10 and 20-year pathways

Proposed pathway How someone may qualify
3 years Earnings of at least £125,141 for three years, or in three of the four years before applying; or qualification through the proposed Highest Talent Group, which remains subject to review.
5 years Earnings of at least £50,271 in three of the previous five years; work in an eligible public service occupation; or a specified British connection.
10 years The standard pathway for people who meet the requirements but do not qualify for a shorter route. The response’s summary table says applicants would need earnings of at least £12,571 in five of the previous seven years.
20 years May apply where a qualifying immigration breach or access to specified public funds prevents someone from using a shorter pathway.

The Government says the earnings thresholds will be linked to relevant income tax thresholds, so they may change over time. The response also recognises that income can vary because of caring responsibilities, parental leave or ill health, and describes a “best years” approach for the different pathways.

There is a point that needs clarification: the response’s narrative says the minimum £12,571 contribution must be demonstrated for at least three years, while its summary table says the 10-year pathway requires earnings at that level in five of the previous seven years. The final Rules or guidance should clarify how these requirements fit together.

What minimum requirements would apply?

The Government says applicants would need to meet mandatory requirements relating to character and suitability, Government debt, English, the Life in the UK test and contribution.

The proposed English standard is B2, subject to exemptions including for children, people aged 65 or over, and people unable to meet the requirement because of a physical or mental condition. The Life in the UK test would remain, with existing exemptions.

The proposed “no Government debt” requirement is broader than the current approach. It would include specified NHS debt, unpaid tax, National Insurance contributions and litigation debt owed to the Home Office. Further detail, including how repayment plans and safeguards would work, is still needed.

The response also proposes a significantly stricter criminality requirement. It says an adult applicant with a criminal record in the UK would be refused settlement. The examples include custodial and suspended sentences, some out-of-court disposals, court-imposed fines, community sentences and certain civil orders following conviction. Overseas convictions may also matter if the underlying conduct would be an offence in the UK. The response says discretion would remain in cases involving offences committed as a child.

How could public funds and immigration breaches affect the pathway?

Under the proposal, applicants seeking to qualify through the 3, 5 or 10-year pathways would generally need not to have accessed specified public funds during the five years immediately before applying. The response describes a 20-year pathway for people who continue to access those funds, subject to the other requirements.

The Government has not yet set out the final list of benefits and support that will count, or the safeguards and exemptions for vulnerable people. A past claim should therefore not be assumed to have a particular effect without checking the final Rules and the person’s circumstances.

Specified immigration breaches committed as an adult—including overstaying, breaching a visa condition, deception in an application or frustrating immigration controls—are proposed to lead to a 20-year pathway. The Government says the qualifying breaches will be set out in the Immigration Rules.

Will time on all visa routes count?

No. The proposals would close the separate 10-year Long Residence route. Time spent on temporary routes—including Student, Graduate, Global Business Mobility, Temporary Worker, Youth Mobility and Seasonal Worker routes—would not count towards the new qualifying period.

The response also proposes that time spent on work or family routes could not be combined with time spent on protection or human rights routes to reach the qualifying period. The rules for people who move between routes will therefore be important.

What about partners and children?

The Government has moved away from requiring every dependant to qualify entirely on an individual basis.

A partner who arrives in the UK with the main applicant may be able to settle at the same time, provided they meet the relevant requirements. A partner who joins later would need to complete the required residence period.

For the minimum economic contribution requirement, eligible couples would be able to combine their earnings to reach a proposed household threshold of £25,142. The response does not say that this combined income automatically qualifies a couple for one of the accelerated earnings pathways.

Children under 18 would be exempt from the proposed income, Government debt, English-language and Life in the UK test requirements, although suitability and criminality requirements would remain relevant. Some young adults who retain child-dependant status, and children who have spent seven years or most of their lives in the UK, would continue to benefit from separate arrangements.

What has the Government decided for care workers and public service workers?

The consultation proposed a 15-year route for many workers in occupations below RQF level 6. The Government has dropped that proposal. Under the response, the standard pathway for those workers would be 10 years, with the possibility of a shorter route if they meet the relevant criteria.

There are targeted transitional arrangements for some people who were already in the UK before publication of the Immigration White Paper in May 2025:

  • Care workers who entered or switched into the route before that date may retain a five-year settlement period if they meet the specified salary, sponsorship and employment conditions. The response sets out a salary figure of £25,000 a year. Those who do not qualify at five years may be able to apply for a further five-year Health and Care visa, subject to the requirements.
  • Certain healthcare and education workers below RQF level 6, including examples such as nursing auxiliaries and teaching assistants, may retain a five-year route if they came to the UK before the White Paper and meet their visa requirements.
  • Certain workers who were already on Skilled Worker routes before April 2024 may be able to extend their visas on existing terms until 2035.

These are specific transitional arrangements, not a general guarantee that everyone already living in the UK will keep their current settlement period.

How would refugees be affected?

The response proposes different settlement pathways for different refugee groups:

  • Refugees admitted through designated safe and legal routes would generally have a five-year pathway. People admitted through the UK Resettlement Scheme would have a lower proposed English requirement of A2 and would not be subject to the five-year public-funds restriction.
  • Refugees granted protection in the UK who move into sustained work, education or training would be able to use the Protection Work and Study route, with a proposed qualifying period of 10 years on that route.
  • Those remaining on Core Protection would generally have a 20-year pathway.
  • Illegal entry may add a further 10 years, subject to the response’s stated safeguard for cases where Article 31 of the Refugee Convention applies.

The response indicates that time spent on Core Protection would not count towards the 10-year Protection Work and Study period after a person transfers to that route. The detailed Rules and safeguards will be important.

Are the EU Settlement Scheme and Windrush affected?

The Government says the EU Settlement Scheme (EUSS) is outside the earned settlement reforms. The response also says Windrush is outside the framework.

Other groups—including some Hong Kong BN(O) visa holders, people on Afghan schemes, members of the Armed Forces and certain vulnerable groups—retain distinct arrangements. However, the Government says some strengthened general requirements may still apply unless an existing exemption or safeguard applies.

What should people do now?

The policy response does not give a start date, and it is not the same as a change to the Immigration Rules. People should continue to check the requirements of their current route and should not assume that the proposed thresholds or time periods already apply.

For anyone approaching settlement, it may be sensible to keep clear records of immigration permission, absences, earnings, employment, dependants, debts and any relevant public funds. The effect of the new framework will depend on the final Rules, including any transitional provisions and the date they take effect.

The Government has said further technical guidance and an impact assessment will be published before implementation. Until then, individual cases should be assessed against the rules in force at the relevant time and the person’s particular circumstances.

How Visa Professionals can help

Visa Professionals Immigration Solicitors can advise on settlement eligibility, current ILR applications and the potential impact of the Government’s earned settlement proposals on your immigration route.

The proposals are not yet a substitute for the Immigration Rules currently in force. If you are approaching settlement or are concerned about how a past immigration issue may affect you, seek advice based on your own immigration history and documents.

Official sources